Sunday, November 22, 2009

SW development is empirical

One should learn from previous experiences and previous mistakes. Even better, one should learn from others experiences and mistakes. In SW development, we have been very good at adapting knowledge from other industries. This has been especially the case with the manufacturing industry. From the Taylorism to the more recently influences of Lean thinking, the SW development theories and practices have borrowed a lot from the manufacturing industry.

But we need to be very aware of the differences in our industries. Manufacturing typically deals with repeatable processes, while SW development is empirical.

In manufacturing, a repeatable process converts consistent inputs into consistent outputs. Repeatable means that the conversion of inputs to outputs can be replicated with little variation. In repeatable process, a small variation on inputs typically translates to a small variation to the outputs. But this is not the case with SW development.

SW development is really creation. And creation is not a highly predictable and repeatable thing. There is too much complexity and variability in the SW creation process; SW creation is an empirical activity.

Dictionary.com Empirical definition:
1. derived from or guided by experience or experiment.
2. depending upon experience or observation alone, without using scientific method or theory, esp. as in medicine.
3. provable or verifiable by experience or experiment.

In manufacturing, a great deal of work is about putting pieces together to build a specific thing. Whereas, in SW development, these pieces are often created, re-created, or customized every time. This is not to simplify the kind of work going on a manufacturing assembly line. My point is that the manufacturing discipline and its pieces of work are more mature, stable and well understood than the SW discipline, and its pieces of work.

Further, in SW development a small variation on inputs can result into a big variation to the outputs. For example, small changes in requirement or the architecture can result in huge differences in the software development and its output.


8 comments:

Esko Luontola said...

A big different between software development and manufacturing industry is that in software the cost of building something is zero. The equivalence of an engineer designing a blueprint is a programmer writing the code - it is the documentation that describes in detail that what should be manufactured. The difference is that building a physical thing based on a blueprint (such as a car, airplane or skyscraper) costs lots of money, but building software is fully automated - a compiler does it in a few seconds with practically no costs.

http://www.bleading-edge.com/Publications/C++Journal/Cpjour2.htm

Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
Anonymous said...
This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.
angelyu said...

ACER TravelMate 3280 Series Laptop batteryACER TravelMate 3280 Series Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 5550 Series Laptop batteryACER Aspire 5550 Series Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 5560 Series Laptop batteryACER Aspire 5560 Series Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 3640 Laptop batteryACER Aspire 3640 Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 3670 Laptop batteryACER Aspire 3670 Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 5540 Series Laptop batteryACER Aspire 5540 Series Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 5590 Laptop batteryACER Aspire 5590 Laptop battery
ACER Extensa 3100 Laptop batteryACER Extensa 3100 Laptop battery
ACER TravelMate 2420 Series Laptop batteryACER TravelMate 2420 Series Laptop battery

angelyu said...

ACER TravelMate 3280 Series Laptop batteryACER TravelMate 3280 Series Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 5550 Series Laptop batteryACER Aspire 5550 Series Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 5560 Series Laptop batteryACER Aspire 5560 Series Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 3640 Laptop batteryACER Aspire 3640 Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 3670 Laptop batteryACER Aspire 3670 Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 5540 Series Laptop batteryACER Aspire 5540 Series Laptop battery
ACER Aspire 5590 Laptop batteryACER Aspire 5590 Laptop battery
ACER Extensa 3100 Laptop batteryACER Extensa 3100 Laptop battery
ACER TravelMate 2420 Series Laptop batteryACER TravelMate 2420 Series Laptop battery

Anonymous said...

Promise me you'll never forget me because if I thought you would I'd never leave IMVU Credits, Sometimes when I say "I'm OK" I just want someone to look me in eyes, hug me tight, and say"I know you're not IMVU Credit, to me, the past is black and white, but the future is always color IMVU Credits.

Unknown said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
cmtech said...


Great article information. thank you
giá cửa gỗ công nghiệp